Lesson 06 · Craft · 3 min read

The crop is killing your idea.

McLuhan said the medium is the message. On a phone, the format is the idea, or the idea dies in the format.

In 1964, Marshall McLuhan wrote that the medium is the message: the shape of a channel changes what people receive, more than the content poured into it. Sixty years later, most campaigns still behave as if he never said it.

The film is shot wide, approved on a laptop in a meeting room, then squeezed into a vertical at the very end, when the budget is gone and the crew has left. The idea was designed for one screen. The audience lives on another.

The phone is not a small TV

People do not watch a phone. They hold it. Thumb first, sound off, one second to decide, the screen inches from their face. Framing that feels epic on a wall feels empty in a hand. Text that reads on a billboard disappears under a caption bar. A slow reveal that works in a cinema is a skip on a feed.

A crop keeps the pixels and loses the intention. The subject ends up small and centred, the context is cut away, the rhythm belongs to a different screen. Your audience senses it instantly: this was not made for me.

If the format is an afterthought, so is your audience.

One idea, many natives

The answer is not to make more content. It is to make one idea strong enough to be reborn in every format, with each version built for the screen it lives on: its own framing, its own close ups, its own first second.

For Albatal, we did not crop the film. We recut it for the phone, with close ups shot for the thumb: the chess board, the pack riding shotgun, the selfie. The vertical was a native, not a leftover.

Plan the cut downs on day one

Format is not delivery. It is part of the idea. McLuhan would have told you that for free.

Next lesson · 07Stop translating your ads. → ← All lessons